Nothing is Hidden

Wittgenstein famously said “Nothing is hidden.” He’s talking about human behavior. His point is there isn’t some hidden realm of human experience– the mind, the private realm. We talk as if these things exist. That isn’t because we are referring to known phenomena or artifacts. When we talk about this rock right in front of (both) of us, we have an object. When we talk about our sensations, .e.g “this afterimage I see right now,” things are quite different.

Consider this game: I tell you I’m thinking of a number between one and five. You have to guess it.

You first try “One.”
I say “Nope.”
You try “Two.”
“Nope.”
You try “Three.”
“Sorry. Still wrong.”
You guess “Four.”
“Jeez, still wrong.”
Finally you say “Okay, five then!”
I Say, “I’m so sorry: still wrong.”
You are pissed. “You said between one and five!”
“I never was thinking of a number.”

Now, during the game, because of the set-up, you acted as if there was this kind of quasi-object, “the number” that was in a weird kind of domain, “my mind.” But I wasn’t playing that game. I was playing a different, “trick you and be annoying” game. So the “picked number object” was just in the game you were playing. Or maybe I was thinking of “1.872.” Again, I was playing a different game.

Wittgenstein says “When our language suggests an object, and there is none, there is, so to speak, a spirit.” The game you were playing had the quasi-object as a feature of the game. That doesn’t mean it really existed in any sense. It was like a paper-thin image or “illusion” that arose from the game. It kind of lurks behind the game. We want to say that to “really” play the game I need to create this object, the chosen number, and keep it fixed, so it behaves in a way analogous to a physical object. The metaphor is that when asked to pick a number I’ve picked up a card with a number on it, from a field of cards with the numbers one through five. This physical analogy is important. It’s the materialist, real situation. The physical analogy is important: the mental operation is kind of a transformation of this operation into “the mind.”

You can imagine that after tens of thousands of years of manipulating physical objects, with the development of language it became became possible and useful to talk about objects that weren’t like this rock, here, but did other useful things. So they exist elsewhere. And when we turn and ask where “elsewhere” is, we end up saying, “in this weird location, the mind.”

There isn’t really space in the physical world for a mental world to exist. There isn’t anything there that can give the mental its “mental” qualities. They are two different sorts of things.

Another game. I take your hand and lay it against mine, so your thumb is against mine, your index finger against my index finger, etc. I ask you to think of a finger. I will probably be able to guess which finger you are thinking of. When you “think” of a finger, to choose it, you tense up that finger. And I can feel this in my finger against it. A card player or con-man knows all about these sorts of “tells.” The point is: to choose the finger you perform a physical ritual of pointing or choosing, and you have to physically do something. Now you can avoid this by “thinking quietly” and just sort of making a “sideways glance” at the finger. But this just amounts to “moving the finger a little.” Or you can get abstract and say “I’ll pick a number between one and five, and that will correspond to the finger, with the thumb as one, etc.’” But this just leaves the “point and connecting” ritual for the future. It is still out there.

A professional poker player tries to not “let his emotions show” while playing. But the point is: you have to make an affirmative effort at this. You have to practice it. Imagine that we devoted all the resources of a small country to reading and analyzing the physical states of a poker player. He was totally wired up and it went to big screens in a control center with hundreds of technicians staring into flat-screens reading all his neural and other physiological activity. Assume we’d studied his reactions for years, his whole life. A huge team that was expert in every twinge of this one person. When he gets a new card from the deck, don’t you think we’d be able to tell quite a lot, just from the reactions of his body?

Another issue with the mental is the fact that it contains two components: an observer or actor, and a field. When we recall a fact we are acting, and we are also the field of action (the thing we search or the place from which we retrieve the information). There is this dual form. But if we are dual in this way, what do we say about the active half? What sort of thing is it? Isn’t it just sort of a reflection of our normal social selves? So we have a whole “self” inside ourselves. And how does it work? Doesn’t it need another whole “self” inside it? Isn’t this an infinite regress. And how does it operate? What is the operation of, say, recalling a phone number? We either remember the number or not. The thoughts and images that may accompany this task are not necessary to the task.

And consider the field, the inner realm. If I ask you “How many windows are there in your home?” you will probably have to sit for a bit. You are moving around your home, in your mind, counting windows. You finally reach a total and tell me. But you could be wrong– maybe you forgot that little window in the corner of the kitchen, or one in the attic, etc. The mental show does not reliably give you the answer because it is not an external source of information . It seems essential, in that you certainly have no idea how many windows there are without taking the mental “tour” of your home. But this dance only gets you in the ballpark of the answer. It is a necessary path to get to any answer, but it doesn’t itself generate the answer.

In summary: The mental is a form of social game. It suggests quasi-objects. When we try to pin these down, we find ourselves in a weird realm “the mind.” We think we can operate here and perform tasks in this realm, but this is just because we’re applying the qualities of a physical location to this mysterious place. When we look at how we use “the mind” we see that it does not actually operate like any sort of location.

0 thoughts on “Nothing is Hidden

  1. HowardRef

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Wonderful tips. Thanks!
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    discount pharmaceuticals trust pharmacy canada prescription drugs online without doctor canadian viagra
    buy prescription drugs online
    canadian prescriptions
    canadian prescription drugs
    mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
    reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
    online pharmacy no prescription

    Reply
  2. HowardRef

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Thank you, A lot of content.
    http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
    prescription drugs canada canadian cialis the canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy
    canada pharmacies online prescriptions
    canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
    canada pharmacies
    legitimate canadian mail order pharmacies
    <a href="http://www.nationwidemarketing.com/blog/?form2mailerror&inquiry=Business+Development&fname=HaroldDon&lname=HaroldDon&email=haroldvaf%40gmail.com&company=google&phone1=88174745129&phone2=81862338725&phone3=88276367377&comments=+Terrific+content.+Kudos%21+http://cialispego.com/+difference+between+viagra+and+cialis+%3Ca+href=%22http://cialismsnrx.com/%22%3Ebuy+cialis+online%3C/a%3E+tomo+cialis+y+no+funciona+%3Ca+href=http://cialisttk.com/%3Ecialis+generic%3C/a%3E?form2mailerror&inquiry=Business Development&fname=Howardcoesy&lname=Howardcoesy&email=zittel020eejf@songwriter.net&company=google&phone1=86754675212&phone2=87923756968&phone3=82383219941&comments= Really quite a lot of awesome facts. https://nicktambone.com/ drugs online canadian pharmacies online canada drugs pharmacy canadian pharmacies-24h canadian prescription drugs most reliable canadian pharmacies medication costs prescription drugs prices trusted overseas pharmacies onlinecanadianpharmacy.com“>canada pharmacies without script
    cheap drugs online

    Reply
  3. HowardRef

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    You actually mentioned it terrifically.
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    canada pharmacies online prescriptions aarp approved canadian online pharmacies canadian family pharmacy northwest pharmacy
    northwestpharmacy
    northwestpharmacy
    us pharmacy no prior prescription
    canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
    canadian drugs without prescription
    prescription drugs prices

    Reply
  4. HowardRef

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Information effectively utilized..
    http://canadianpharmacymim.com/
    online pharmacies canada online pharmacies of canada best canadian pharmacies canada pharmaceutical online ordering
    overseas pharmacy forum
    canadian drug store
    canada pharmacies prescription drugs
    canada pharmacies online
    canadian prescriptions
    canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs

    Reply
  5. HowardRef

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Regards! I value this!
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    best canadian online pharmacy canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy no prescription needed canada pharmaceutical online ordering
    mexican pharmacy online medications
    canadian pharmacies online
    best online pharmacies canada
    online discount pharmacy
    no prior prescription required pharmacy
    canadian pharmacies shipping to usa

    Reply
  6. HowardRef

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Beneficial facts. Many thanks!
    http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/
    legitimate online pharmacies canada drugs online pharmacy no prescription needed london drugs canada
    canadian pharmacy reviews
    <a href="http://tradea.fi/albumi/uusimmat_kuvat/2145103?m=+++Thanks.+A+good+amount+of+forum+posts.++++http://canadianpharmacyntx.com/+++best+online+canadian+pharcharmy+%3Ca+href=%22http://canadianpharmacysilo.com/%22%3Ecanadian+pharmaceuticals+online%3C/a%3E+canadapharmacy+canada+pharmaceuticals+online+++%3Ca+href=%22http://obatherbalterbaik.web.id/obat-herbal-terbaik-untuk-penebalan-dinding-rahim/?unapproved=405487&moderation-hash=6c0b9256e5e6124b3f10755cfc11090e#comment-405487%22%3Etrusted+overseas+pharmacies%3C/a%3E+++%3Ca+href=%22http://myaym.com/product/logo-t-shirt/?unapproved=15795&moderation-hash=fbb7b3f762b38f44f5a4745721f16d20#comment-15795%22%3Epharmacy+price+compare%3C/a%3E+++%3Ca+href=%22http://www.personlig-coach.com/generating-traffic-through-search/?unapproved=4394&moderation-hash=964b47a0e9a90ef267310c39ed229a74#comment-4394%22%3Etop+rated+online+canadian+pharmacies%3C/a%3E+++%3Ca+href=%22http://mks2017.uw.edu.pl/2016/12/12/witaj-swiecie/?unapproved=12195&moderation-hash=9305ba8d4a2c710ec38d708eff5605d8#comment-12195%22%3Eprescription+price+comparison%3C/a%3E+++%3Ca+href=%22http://blogi.dziennikzachodni.pl/technoblogia/2015/11/08/3708/screenshot_2015-11-05-18-58-29/?unapproved=45798&moderation-hash=b1a4700123ea7b608366431f4426f51d#comment-45798%22%3Eprescription+cost%3C/a%3E+++%3Ca+href=%22http://stefannibrasil.me/github-guide-for-open-source-contributions/#comment-16070%22%3Ecanadian+drug+stores+online%3C/a%3E&s=Howardneown&err=captcha#album_comment”>canadadrugs
    canadian online pharmacies prescription drugs
    mexican pharmacy online medications
    prescription without a doctor’s prescription
    legitimate online pharmacies

    Reply
  7. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Many thanks. An abundance of data!
    http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
    canadapharmacy com north west pharmacy canada best online pharmacies canada canadian pharmacies without an rx
    reputable canadian mail order pharmacies
    best price prescription drugs
    buy prescription drugs without doctor
    canadapharmacyonline.com
    prescription drug assistance
    buy prescription drugs without doctor

    Reply
  8. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Good postings. Regards.
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    reputable canadian mail order pharmacies northwestpharmacy highest rated canadian pharmacies canadian pharmacy online
    canada online pharmacies
    trust pharmacy canada
    online pharmacy without a prescription
    walmart pharmacy price check
    mail order pharmacies
    canada pharmacies online

    Reply
  9. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Kudos. A lot of data.
    http://www.canadianpharmacymsn.com/
    canadian online pharmacy aarp approved canadian online pharmacies visit poster’s website mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
    online pharmacy no prescription needed
    no prescription online pharmacy
    online canadian pharmacy
    no prescription pharmacies
    canada drugs pharmacy
    approved canadian pharmacies online

    Reply
  10. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    You actually said it terrifically.
    http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
    best online international pharmacies northwest pharmacy buy prescription drugs canada online pharmacies of canada
    canadian pharmacies without prescriptions
    visit poster’s website
    rx price comparison
    prescription drugs without prior prescription
    pharmacies near me
    mexican online pharmacies

    Reply
  11. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Superb tips. Regards.
    http://canadianonlinepharmacynnm.com/
    canada pharmacies online top rated canadian pharmacies online canadian pharmacy uk delivery mexican pharmacies shipping to usa
    buy prescription drugs from canada
    pharmacy prescription
    drug price
    best canadian prescription prices
    canada drugs online
    canadian pharmacy without prescription

    Reply
  12. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Very well voiced indeed. !
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    highest rated canadian pharmacies mexican pharmacies shipping to usa pain meds online without doctor prescription canadian viagra
    best online canadian pharcharmy
    online pharmacies canada
    canadian pharmacies online
    mail order pharmacy
    <a href="http://vincent.bonduau.free.fr/?s=+Amazing+a+good+deal+of+wonderful+advice%21+http%3A%2F%2Ftalahicc.com%2F+best+online+pharmacy+stores+trust+pharmacy+canada+trusted+overseas+pharmacies+canadian+pharmacies+that+ship+to+us+%0D%0Aonline+pharmacy+no+prescription+needed+%0D%0Acheap+prescription+drugs+%0D%0Acanadian+drugstore+online+%0D%0Adrug+costs+%0D%0Areputable+canadian+mail+order+pharmacies+%0D%0Acanadian+pharmacy+365″>canadian rx
    best online canadian pharcharmy

    Reply
  13. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Amazing many of awesome facts.
    http://talahicc.com/
    canadian pharmacy canada pharmaceutical online ordering drugs online canadian pharmacies-24h
    canadian rx pharmacy online
    my canadian pharmacy
    canadian prescription drugstore
    pharmacy prices
    <a href="http://www.badlemming.com/?s=You+stated+this+exceptionally+well.+http%3A%2F%2Fcanadianpharmaciesnnm.com%2F+online+prescription+drugs+northwestpharmacy+canada+drug+canadian+cialis+%0D%0Acanada+online+pharmacies+%0D%0A<a+href%3D%22https%3A%2F%2Ffuszereslelek.nlcafe.hu%2F2018%2F10%2F24%2Fmakos-szilvalekvaros-pite%2F%23comments%3FsharebyemailCimzett%3Dstolzenberg334ziz%2540dutchmail.com%26sharebyemailFelado%3Dstolzenberg334ziz%2540dutchmail.com%26sharebyemailUzenet%3D%2B%250D%250AReally%2Ba%2Bgood%2Bdeal%2Bof%2Bsuperb%2Bmaterial%2521%2B%250D%250Ahttp%253A%252F%252Fviagrapego.com%252F%2B%250D%250Acheap%2Bmeltabs%2Bviagra%2B%250D%250Aviagra%2Bonline%2B%250D%250Apurchase%2Bdiscount%2Bviagra%2Bon%2Bthe%2Binternet%2B%250D%250Aviagra%2Bfor%2Bwomen%26sharebyemailTitle%3DMakos-szilvalekvaros%2Bpite%26sharebyemailUrl%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Ffuszereslelek.nlcafe.hu%252F2018%252F10%252F24%252Fmakos-szilvalekvaros-pite%252F%26shareByEmailSendEmail%3DElkuld%22>buy+cialis+%0D%0Abuying+drugs+canada+%0D%0Aboard+of+pharmacy+%0D%0Apharmacy+online+mexico+%0D%0Acanadian+drugs+without+prescription”>best online pharmacies canada
    approved canadian pharmacies online

    Reply
  14. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Thanks a lot. A lot of stuff.
    http://canadianpharmaciescubarx.com/
    canadian pharmacy 365 canada pharmaceutical online ordering online canadian pharmacies north west pharmacy canada
    canadian pharmacy king
    canadapharmacyonline.com
    best online international pharmacies
    prescription drugs online without doctor
    pharmacy online mexico
    canada pharmacy online orders

    Reply
  15. Quentinmed

    Your comment is awaiting moderation. This is a preview, your comment will be visible after it has been approved.

    Superb data. Many thanks!
    http://canadianpharmaciesnnm.com/
    canadadrugs.com pharmacy canada pharmaceuticals online the canadian pharmacy canada pharmacy
    us pharmacy no prior prescription
    canadian pharmacies shipping to usa
    <a href="http://www.ikeaclub.biz.ua/lib/ajax/contact_us_form.php?form_ajax=contacts&name=Quentinnax&email=zittel020eejf%40songwriter.net&phone=86937864381&message=+Kudos%2C+A+lot+of+knowledge.++https%3A%2F%2Fnicktambone.com%2F+discount+pharmacy+online+canada+pharmacy+online+highest+rated+canadian+pharmacies+north+west+pharmacy+canada+%0D%0Abest+non+prescription+online+pharmacies+%0D%0Acanadian+pharmacies+online+prescriptions+%0D%0Aonline+pharmacies+canada+%0D%0Apharmacy+cost+comparison+%0D%0Adrug+prices+comparison+%0D%0Adrugs+without+prescription&security_code=%21UNKNOWN_TYPE%21&send=”>best online international pharmacies
    canada online pharmacy
    pharmacy price comparison
    canada pharmacies without script

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *